American Idol Features

Who Won 'American Idol'

May 21, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/david-cook/564984' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>David Cook</font></a> Wins

"I congratulate David Cook. He is a true talent and performed wonderfully throughout the season. He will have a stellar career ... I believe that David Archuleta will also have a wonderful career. He has an amazing and beautiful voice. In my opinion, his vocal range and ability to hit notes is worlds better than the other David's. They are so different, yet both are blessed with immense talent."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2161797&func=6&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">JavaConroy </font></a></p>

Who Won 'American Idol'

May 21, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/david-cook/564984' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>David Cook</font></a> Wins

"Finally a winner who deserves it!!! I'm so happy David Cook won. ... I think he's very worthy of it. He has it all. The great voice that can change up any song and make it his own. He's got a personality and charisma which is more then I can say of Archie. That same boring face week after week and same boring and slow songs ... gosh I wanted to scream watching him."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2161787&func=6&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">Vintagediva74 </font></a></p>

Who Won 'American Idol'

May 21, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/david-cook/564984' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>David Cook</font></a> Wins

"I am so happy he won!! What a great guy. Through his winning he went over and put his arm around David A. He is a true gentleman. I thought that was the sweetest thing. Yes he was crying. So was I. People are allowed to cry from pure joy ... I also thought David A. handled it beautifully and I think he is going to be just fine. He is an amazing singer and he will blossom as the years go by."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2161592&func=6&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">GretchenMayfield </font></a></p>

Who Won 'American Idol'

May 21, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/david-cook/564984' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>David Cook</font></a> Wins

"After a disastrous performance Tuesday night, David Cook's FAN BASE rallied around him, charged to the telephones and called, called, called like never before. David Cook's fans won it for him. Thank you. Even Simon Cowell knew he was too hard on David Cook and apologized to hime right before the announcement."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2161615&func=6&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">DodgeRH5 </font></a></p>

Who Won 'American Idol'

May 21, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/david-cook/564984' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>David Cook</font></a> Wins

"Finally a rocker wins! ABOUT TIME!! Here I thought we would never see a rocker win this ... good work everyone!! Cook deserves it."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2161543&func=6&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">feistybritchies2 </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

May 21, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/david-archuleta/564981' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>David Archuleta</font></a> Is Eliminated

"I'll never watch 'American Idol' again. Completely disagree with the choice -- David A is FAR SUPERIOR to Cook."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2161442&func=6&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">TrudyGary </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

May 21, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/david-archuleta/564981' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>David Archuleta</font></a> Is Eliminated

"David A. seemed genuinely happy for David C., and Davis A's much maligned Dad was smiling and applauding David C. Very nice. It was so nice when David C. put his arm around Davis A. and they both looked quite happy. Both do quite well in the future."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2161887&func=5&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">JavaConroy </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

May 21, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/david-archuleta/564981' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>David Archuleta</font></a> Is Eliminated

"[David A.'s] father is going to go on a shooting rampage. Everyone better watch out. After that he is going to give David the beat down of his life for losing."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2161403&func=6&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">TLiltz </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

May 21, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/david-archuleta/564981' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>David Archuleta</font></a> Is Eliminated

"To David Archuleta: You did an amazing job this season, and have every reason to be proud of yourself. Your family, your friends and all of your fans are also proud of you. Well done!!"<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2161819&func=6&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">Zeldafan358 </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

May 14, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/syesha-mercado/565001' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Syesha</font></a> Is Eliminated

"I knew it was coming, but I'm really happy she made it this far. Congrats Syesha, big things are in her future."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2149017&func=6&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">Denicci1977 </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

May 14, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/syesha-mercado/565001' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Syesha</font></a> Is Eliminated

"What a darling girl! She is the whole package -- talent, beauty and class -- we've not heard the last of her. She's gonna be a huge Broadway star."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2149118&func=5&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">BESTBUNNY10 </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

May 14, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/syesha-mercado/565001' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Syesha</font></a> Is Eliminated

"No surprise but not because I think this has been planned. Both of [the Davids] have never been in bottom three. People must have voted for them consistently."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2149093&func=5&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">Wimanushight </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

May 14, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/syesha-mercado/565001' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Syesha</font></a> Is Eliminated

"Thank goodness. A very pretty girl with a very ordinary voice. She is no Jennifer Hudson, Fantasia or Melinda Doolittle that is for sure! Carly could out sing her, Brooke had more soul and personality, Kristie Lee was more fun and yet she out-beat them all. Go figure"<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2149085&func=5&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">DBrayDee </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

May 14, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/syesha-mercado/565001' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Syesha</font></a> Is Eliminated

"Syesha has a foot up IMO. She will have a great career on Broadway and maybe movies or sitcoms. She is not just a singer."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2149278&func=5&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">Cybrgaga4 </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

May 14, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/syesha-mercado/565001' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Syesha</font></a> Is Eliminated

"The Final Two will deliver a great show next week; I'm really looking forward to it! This will be one of the best years for the final show that 'AI' has ever had. People can go back and forth here about who is 'The Best,' and I'm disgusted by the unfair criticism here of either young man. They are different, and I appreciate and celebrate those differences."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2149128&func=6&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">Ashebury </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

May 7, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/jason-castro/564991' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Jason</font></a> Is Eliminated

"What a sweetheart! I'm glad we got to keep him to the final 4. He did look happy and as usual ... cracked me up with his attitude and humor. Even with him leaving, he just makes ya smile."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2140660&func=5&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">TEKKELL </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

May 7, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/jason-castro/564991' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Jason</font></a> Is Eliminated

"Congratulations everyone, we have a talent contest! The three most talented singers survive and advance to the next round. Jason didn't perform and deserved to go home. Jason shot the tambourine!."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2140602&func=6&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">DodgeRH5 </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

May 7, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/jason-castro/564991' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Jason</font></a> Is Eliminated

"Ryan Seacrest announced there were 51 million votes with only a million votes separating the top three contestants ... that's scary. What that means is there is no clear-cut favorite contrary to what you Archie and Cookie fans may wish to believe! Ladies and gentlemen, we got ourselves a horserace!."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2140754&func=6&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">DodgeRH5 </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

May 7, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/jason-castro/564991' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Jason</font></a> Is Eliminated

"After Jason Castro left tonight I am done with 'Idol' period. And not because he was voted off ... I thought the way he was treated stunk and set him up to fail. I mean in the rewind they even showed Simon saying he was fantastic at times ... They want a David vs David finish mark my words its all scripted."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2140713&func=6&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">Carramea55 </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

May 7, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/jason-castro/564991' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Jason</font></a> Is Eliminated

"Syesha made it to the top three and I for one am very happy she did and that life took this moment to be fair!"<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2140614&func=6&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">MzFam4 </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

May 7, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/jason-castro/564991' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Jason</font></a> Is Eliminated

"I didn't want to see him go either, but I think he wanted to leave. He'll be better off with people that appreciate his style."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2140631&func=5&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">Dsrtflwr30 </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

April 30, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/brooke-white/564873' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Brooke</font></a> Is Eliminated

"It is so sad Brooke leaving. Love her heart -- she is such a sweetheart of a gal. I cried with her."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2132282&func=5&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">Ka8tydid </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

April 30, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/brooke-white/564873' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Brooke</font></a> Is Eliminated

"It's only 10 episodes too late, now Jason needs to go next. Her exit song captured how awful she is ... Now she can go play in a coffee house and annoy those people."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2132315&func=5&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">karinam676 </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

April 30, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/brooke-white/564873' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Brooke</font></a> Is Eliminated

"I admit I wanted Brooke eliminated, but it is sad how hard she took it. She needs to try and work on being a stronger person. I wish her luck in her career."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2132352&func=5&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">Sam4peaceonearth </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

April 30, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/brooke-white/564873' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Brooke</font></a> Is Eliminated

"Finally! She should have been gone a while back. Just because she is 'sweet,' doesn't mean she should stick around."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2132302&func=6&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">Bonogirlu2 </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

April 30, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/brooke-white/564873' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Brooke</font></a> Is Eliminated

"She wasn't cut out for this type of pressure and this type of exposure. Although I enjoyed her performances ... she is too timid for the spotlight like this. She should pursue her own genre of music and be able to sing what she wants, in her style."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2132313&func=6&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">Dsrtflwr30 </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

April 23, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/carly-smithson/564874' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Carly</font></a> Is Eliminated

"I thought Carly was the best of the night last night with David Cook, and Syesha hot on her heels. Boy, was I ever out of step. America prefered Brooke & Jason. I might as well give up."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2123930&func=5&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">PLFarrar </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

April 23, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/carly-smithson/564874' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Carly</font></a> Is Eliminated

"It's been said so often but this is supposed to be about SINGING! Every year this happens but just as in life, popularity comes and then goes, true gifts remain. I look forward to buing Carly's first CD!"<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2123651&func=6&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">gsr852 </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

April 23, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/carly-smithson/564874' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Carly</font></a> Is Eliminated

"Brooke should have been eliminated before Carly. Carly's performance last night was very substantial. Brooke fluffed it as usual. Brooke staying and Carly going is a pathetic JOKE."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2123700&func=6&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4"> The Mups</font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

April 23, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/carly-smithson/564874' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Carly</font></a> Is Eliminated

"I never did connect with Carly but I do realize she is talented. I wish her the best...she is going to do fine I am sure."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2123659&func=5&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">Ka8tydid </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

April 23, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/carly-smithson/564874' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Carly</font></a> Is Eliminated

"American wants ballads. I said it before. It's the year of the ballad. Even when David Cook rocks it out, he does it at a slower, smoother pace, with the BIG notes. Some complain that David A always 'sounds the same' but guess what? It works! The bottom two were the ones that picked up the pace. Would Carly still be there if she had gone with her first choice of 'All I Ask'? Seriously ... a big ballad with moving lyrics might just have saved her."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2123660&func=6&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">Annewahm </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

April 17, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/kristy-lee-cook/564995' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Kristy</font></a> Is Eliminated

"She was the most improved from the start of the season. I thought she was better than Carly and Brooke the past two weeks. Oh well, it was inevitable."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2116067&func=5&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">CaryBrothersFan </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

April 17, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/kristy-lee-cook/564995' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Kristy</font></a> Is Eliminated

"Yee ha!! It's about ... time! When I think of others that left before her though, I could just scream."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2116151&func=5&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">RNSHOTMASTER </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

April 17, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/kristy-lee-cook/564995' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Kristy</font></a> Is Eliminated

"Kellie Pickler started out as a joke on 'Idol' because she was so naive. But she grew worldly later and is now a star. Kristy has a lot of spunk and a pretty good voice. Kristy always had that country twang in all her songs. She will get a country deal, that's for sure!"<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2116118&func=5&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">Sexymamacita458 </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

April 17, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/kristy-lee-cook/564995' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Kristy</font></a> Is Eliminated

"David Archuleta made one of the smartest decisions of the contest this year when Ryan asked him a 'trap' question for him to join the group he thought would safe. He refused to go to either side but sat in the middle of the floor. He showed no disrespect to anyone."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2116138&func=6&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">DodgeRH5 </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

April 17, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/kristy-lee-cook/564995' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Kristy</font></a> Is Eliminated

"How could all of the polls have it wrong? It leads me to believe that the show is rigged. Syesha or Brooke should have went."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2116271&func=5&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">Mikeys1 </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

April 10, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/michael-johns/564998' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Michael</font></a> Is Eliminated

"Michael had it all. He [had] the best voice, stage presence, looks ... America totally got it wrong!"<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2109202&func=6&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">Psychhale </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

April 10, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/michael-johns/564998' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Michael</font></a> Is Eliminated

"Michael will do a Daughtry. He'll become more famous now. And deservedly so!!"<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2109222&func=6&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">Zeldafan358 </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

April 10, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/michael-johns/564998' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Michael</font></a> Is Eliminated

"Cook and Archie can do everything Michael does vocally and do it better. Michael a good singer with awesome lady appeal but he just isn't a great singer. I think the other guys took his votes away."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2109210&func=6&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">PETCRAB </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

April 10, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/michael-johns/564998' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Michael</font></a> Is Eliminated

"Is there a fix? Seems to me that Michael should have made it through with ease. You have to wonder if the producers just to get a lot of people upset mess with the numbers at times."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2109260&func=6&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">JAVKIV </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

April 10, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/michael-johns/564998' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Michael</font></a> Is Eliminated

"Get over it people. Michael was lacking in more ways than one. His voice was nothing great and he was missing something."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2109232&func=6&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">Nofinerdh </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

April 10, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/michael-johns/564998' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Michael</font></a> Is Eliminated

"I'd say one of [the Davids] is assured the win, now. Michael was the only other contender. I'm guessing Cook will pick up most of his votes, so Archie could be in trouble."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2109350&func=6&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">PLFarrar </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

April 2, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/ramiele-malubay/564999' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Ramiele</font></a> Is Eliminated

"I think [Ramiele's] got a great voice but is one who should have waited a couple of years to do this. Musically, she's not as grown up as she needs to be, but may well be someday."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2101755&func=6&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">Lmolldrem </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

April 2, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/ramiele-malubay/564999' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Ramiele</font></a> Is Eliminated

"We get 2 more weeks of Kristy ... I don't know how good of a consolation prize that is. But at least she's more exciting than Ramiele."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2101738&func=6&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">brewerwitchesno1 </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

April 2, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/ramiele-malubay/564999' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Ramiele</font></a> Is Eliminated

"[Ramiele] has a powerful voice but didn't use it to her benefit. Lesser singers like Kristy and Brooke are still there because they know how to artfully play the game. Rami was too young and innocent. Darling girl though."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2101985&func=5&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">BESTBUNNY10 </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

April 2, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/ramiele-malubay/564999' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Ramiele</font></a> Is Eliminated

"I was very relieved when [Brooke] was finally safe. Brooke is one of the best and one of the outstanding ones"<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2101783&func=5&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">Goldie2244 </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

April 2, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/ramiele-malubay/564999' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Ramiele</font></a> Is Eliminated

"Yay, Kristy Lee is safe! At least another week or 2 for Kristy! Sorry, Ramiele fans! Ramiele had a beautiful tone to her voice! It was sad to see her go! As long as Michael and Kristy are safe, I'm happy!"<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2101884&func=6&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">PinkSunset77 </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

March 26, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/chikezie-eze/564875' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Chikezie</font></a> Is Eliminated

"Chikezie was fabulous. But I don't think that 'American Idol' viewers are his true audience. Hopefully 'AI' will give him exposure for a succesful vocal career. I know that I will go see him in concert."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2095525&func=5&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">Luckwaster2 </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

March 26, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/chikezie-eze/564875' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Chikezie</font></a> Is Eliminated

"Nice voice but a dud in every other way. That's probably why he's very single too."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2095484&func=6&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">PETCRAB </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

March 26, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/chikezie-eze/564875' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Chikezie</font></a> Is Eliminated

"Yes, [Ramiele]'s a good singer but her performances have been less than stellar. How does she manage to not only stay, but not make the bottom three?"<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2095580&func=6&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">SLPerea </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

March 26, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/chikezie-eze/564875' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Chikezie</font></a> Is Eliminated

"[Jason] is a cutie! I hope he kicks up his performance next week so I don't have to worry."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2095476&func=6&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">Winterblues2008 </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

March 19, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/amanda-overmyer/564870' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Amanda</font></a> Is Eliminated

"I've been an Amanda fan since the beginning, and I've always said that she wouldn't make it far, because she does not fall into the cookie-cutter pop category that 'AI' puts out. It really is a shame she had to go, but I believe she will have great opportunities ahead of her!"<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2089137&func=6&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">Dsrtflwr30</font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

March 19, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/amanda-overmyer/564870' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Amanda</font></a> Is Eliminated

"Amanda has been compared to Ms. Joplin ... give me a break she's no Joplin. Amanda has an attitude. She embarrassed Kristy when Kristy tried to hug her, Amanda gave her the brush off ... Sorry but America got it right."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2089029&func=6&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">BettyW751 </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

March 19, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/amanda-overmyer/564870' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Amanda</font></a> Is Eliminated

"What in the world is happening here. AMANDA LEAVES? She was a really good singer. ... And for the love of God, how can stinking Kristy escape the boot AGAIN? Something is not right here."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2089029&func=6&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">Dollarmonster2 </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

March 19, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/amanda-overmyer/564870' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Amanda</font></a> Is Eliminated

"There was no way Carly should have been in the bottom 3. She had the best performance of the night last night!"<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2089205&func=5&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">PineTreeHugs </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

March 12, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/david-hernandez/564989' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>David H.</font></a> Is Eliminated

"He didn't pick a good song and it wasn't his best performance but does he deserve to go home? NO!!! At least he didn't forget his words."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2082442&func=5&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">BESTBUNNY10 </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

March 12, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/david-hernandez/564989' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>David H.</font></a> Is Eliminated

"Gee, I wonder why David was sent home tonight, because it sure as H*LL wasn't because he sang bad last night!!! 'AI' was looking for a way to get rid of him because of his past, and they did it. I don't even want to watch the show anymore."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2082497&func=5&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">SkittL1123 </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

March 12, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/david-hernandez/564989' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>David H.</font></a> Is Eliminated

"Kristy was so bad last night that when she sang again tonight I muted the TV. Yet, she stayed??!! She was is so awful."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2082553&func=6&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">Witchw21 </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

March 12, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/david-hernandez/564989' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>David H.</font></a> Is Eliminated

"I rated Syesha as the 4th best performance last night but thought she'd be going home if anyone was. I would not have been surprised if Kristy had gone home even though I tend to rate her higher than most people. I was mildly surprised David H. went home. I think there is less difference in the talent between the best 3 and the worst 3 so I wouldn't be real surprised anymore no matter who went home."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2082491&func=5&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">CaryBrothersFan </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

March 6, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/asiah-epperson/564872' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Asia'H</font></a> Is Eliminated

"If I was there, I would have boo'd too. Asia'h in no way, shape, or form deserved to go home. <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/kristy-lee-cook/564995' target='_blank'>Kristy Lee</a> should have been gone. Some good singers went home last week and a great one went home tonight."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2077044&func=6&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">eab081190 </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

March 6, 2008: <A href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/kady-malloy/564994' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Kady</font></a> Is Eliminated

"Kady just wasn't doing it. I don't think in the past 3 weeks she has had one good performance. Yes, last night was a bit better but maybe just too little too late."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2077124&func=5&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">Heavensrose17 </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

March 6, 2008: <A href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/luke-menard/564996' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Luke</font></a> Is Eliminated

"Puke Menard, I mean Luke, is FINALLY GONE!!!!!!!!!!!!"<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2076915&func=6&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">brewerwitchesno1 </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

March 6, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/danny-noriega/564980' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Danny</font></a> Is Eliminated

"I seem to be in the minority but I really really liked Danny. I thought he was cute as a button, had a good voice and was able to put on a performance. I liked his version of 'Tainted Love' and I loved his attitude. Danny was unique and different. I hope he goes far in life."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2077039&func=6&channel=Television' target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">Alexandliese </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

Feb. 28, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/robbie-carrico/565000' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Robbie</font></a> Is Eliminated

"What a surprise on Robbie. I didn't think he'd go so early"<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2071724&func=5&channel=Television" target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">KamakaLo1</font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

Feb. 28, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/alexandrea-lushington/564869/' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Alexandrea</font></a> Is Eliminated

"Alex nor <A href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/alaina-whitaker/564867' target='_blank'>Alaina</a> should have went home tonight. They were some of the best vocalists. What's going on?"<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2071700&func=6&channel=Television'"target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">eab081190</font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

Feb. 28, 2008: <A href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/alaina-whitaker/564867' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Alaina</font></a> Is Eliminated

"Alaina was better than <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/kady-malloy/564994' target='_blank'>Kady</a>. Kady should have gone home."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2071672&func=5&channel=Television'"target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">TGirl1045</font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

Feb. 28, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/jason-yeager/564992' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Jason Y.</font></a> Is Eliminated

"[Jason] was the easiest prediction I think there's ever been on 'Idol.'"<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2071621&func=5&channel=Television'"target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">RH2458</font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

Feb. 21, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/colton-david-berry/564979' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Colton</font></a> Is Eliminated

"I'm fine with the four that went home. Good luck to them, thoughl."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2066821&func=5&channel=Television'"target="_blank"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">PineTreeHugs</font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

Feb. 21, 2008: <a href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/amy-davis/237334' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Amy</font></a> Is Eliminated

"I was sorry to see Amy go so soon. I thought she had a lot of potential. But, she picked a horrible song to sing!"<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2066665&func=6&channel=Television"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">Winterblues2008 </font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

Feb. 21, 2008: <A href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/garrett-haley/564990' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Garrett</font></a> Is Eliminated

"I think I'm the only one on the board that thinks he sounded pretty good."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2065246&func=6&channel=Television"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">PETCRAB</font></a></p>

Who Got Kicked Off 'American Idol'

Feb. 21, 2008: <A href='http://television.aol.com/celebrity/joanne-borgella/564993' target='_blank'><FONT COLOR='#2864B4'>Joanne</font></a> Is Eliminated

"I think [Joanne] is a far better singer then many others, but I think the flu and the nerves got to her -- I would have liked to see more of her."<br><p align="right">-- <A HREF="http://messageboards.aol.com/aol/en_us/articles.php?boardId=525132&articleId=2066883&func=6&channel=Television"><FONT COLOR="#2864B4">LadyBugsFavGrand</font></a></p>

More 'Idol' Features

See All Features
How to Beat David Archuleta

How to Beat David Archuleta

Can the frontrunner be defeated?

Idol Lookalikes

'Idol' Celebrity Lookalikes

Which star does Danny Noriega resemble?

Simon Cowell Quotes

Simon Says: Nasty Cowell Quotes

Simon's most brutal jabs, cuts and critiques