American Idol' Season 8 Results
March 26, 2009: Michael Sarver Is Eliminated
"I knew he wouldn't win, but he was always a Southern gentleman with great manners. Kudos to him!"
-- WeezSqueez2
Fox
March 26, 2009: Michael Sarver Is Eliminated
"DANG it ... I am really bummed. NO WAY did he sing worse than Megan last night. She was a train wreck!"
-- taosunset200
Fox
March 26, 2009: Matt Giraud Lands in the Bottom 3
"Can someone tell me why Matt Giraud is in the bottom 3 when Simon complimented him for progressing to become one of the better singers in the competition and most people had him in the TOP 5? ... All the women thought he was sexy good! Something's wrong here ..."
-- CornStove7
Fox
March 26, 2009: Michael Sarver Is Eliminated
"Michael seemed like a very classy guy, glad ... he left with his head up. I wish him luck. As far as the weird voting [results], I probably should be used to the surprises after all these seasons but I still find myself wondering how things go sometimes."
Fox
March 18, 2009: Alexis Grace Is Eliminated
"Judges made a BIG mistake ... this is the one time they should have exercised their save ... Alexis was a better singer then at least 3-5 other contestants and is cute to boot!"
-- Dsacco821
Fox
March 18, 2009: Alexis Grace Is Eliminated
"She should have sang that song as a soft ballad throughout the entire song, last night and tonight. She was trying to hard tonight to get that so-called 'dirty' sound. It wasn't suited for that song and she was too emotional to hit the notes tonight. A slow, soft version might have gotten her a reprieve."
-- Ferlin1890
Fox
March 18, 2009: Alexis Grace Is Eliminated
"Can anyone explain to me why Allison Iraheta was in the bottom 3 as I thought she was and still is one of the TOP 5 singers there? Are you telling me she got less votes than Megan, Lil, or even half the guys? I just can't believe that. What's going on here? It appears like another Michael Johns is brewing here."
-- CornStove7
Fox
March 18, 2009: Alexis Grace Is Eliminated
"I personally like Megan more than Alexis, but I like Alexis too. If one of the girls had to go I would have chosen Lil, but I think a guy should have gone (Scott, Michael, or Anoop). Top 10 consists of 7 guys and 3 girls now."
-- PineTreeHugs
Fox
March 11, 2009: Jorge Nunez Is Eliminated
"I was disappointed too that Jorge got the ax on the first show. Boooo. There were at least 4 others that could have gone first."
-- NiNi C 47
Fox
March 11, 2009: Anoop Desai Moves On
"I actually don't think [Jorge or Anoop] are good enough vocally to be the next American Idol but if I had to choose one to stay for me it would be Anoop over Jorge. In my opinion Anoop had more of the entertainment factor about him that made him more entertaining to watch and listen to."
Fox
Reader Comments (Page 6 of 16)
Megan is a beautiful woman but she can`t sing. She should have not even made past the top 1,000.
The only reason Megan is still there is that ... simply ...Simon likes her looks. It's happened every season with him - a pretty girl stays way beyond her time.
I hate to see Michael go. Granted, he wasn't the best singer left, but still, he was very good and such a class act guy! He definitely should have stayed and Megan go home. I think Michael enjoyed watching his last video more than anyone I've ever seen -- I mean truly enjoyed it! I loved that!.....Per comments about Scott, I think he's a great singer and piano player. I love what he's done so far. As great an entertainer and singer as Adam is, I'd much rather listen to songs by Scott vs. Adam. And I love the heart that Scott puts into his songs. His songs touch my heart.
I think Michael was a good singer!! His performance was excellent. My favorite Is Danny. Danny will always Be an American Idol if he doesn't win, But he should win. I like them all this season!! I dont think its fair if you base your vote on the week before because people got better with the critiscism. I dont think they will use thier save until Danny, Adam ,or Lil Rounds are booted off. They will probably try to use it at the end. And remmemmber it is all based on that life-changing performance!!
Could not believe Matt Giraud was in the bottom 3. Megan should have been in the bottom three. Adam Lambert should win this and not geeky Danny Gokey. Did anyone notice how bad Stevie Wonder sang last night?
JD, you must like Barry Manilow and Danny Osmond too.... LOL
This wasn't Megan Joy's best week, but I LOVE her vocals! I also love how she doesn't seem to care that she's gorgeous. She has a quirky, goofy style that is endearing, and every song she sings is completely memorable to me. I heard that "put your records on" song time after time in my life, and it never really registered with me until Megan sang it. I don't think she'll be the number one, but she's MY number one! I hope she lasts a lot longer!
Meghan is terrible. The worst one.
I also think Megan should of been the next to go- people if you want to see Megan off next week YOU HAVE TO VOTE!!!
If you don't vote then how can you comment on her staying? I really hope Danny wins.
Megan is just about USELESS, but so was Michael. In fact, nobody this season is actually "Idol" material, except maybe Adam. He's about the best this season has got!
Think about it, do you really think they'll eliminate another girl before a guy? Somehow I think the votes are manipulated to make the numbers even...