American Idol' Season 8 Results
March 26, 2009: Michael Sarver Is Eliminated
"I knew he wouldn't win, but he was always a Southern gentleman with great manners. Kudos to him!"
-- WeezSqueez2
Fox
March 26, 2009: Michael Sarver Is Eliminated
"DANG it ... I am really bummed. NO WAY did he sing worse than Megan last night. She was a train wreck!"
-- taosunset200
Fox
March 26, 2009: Matt Giraud Lands in the Bottom 3
"Can someone tell me why Matt Giraud is in the bottom 3 when Simon complimented him for progressing to become one of the better singers in the competition and most people had him in the TOP 5? ... All the women thought he was sexy good! Something's wrong here ..."
-- CornStove7
Fox
March 26, 2009: Michael Sarver Is Eliminated
"Michael seemed like a very classy guy, glad ... he left with his head up. I wish him luck. As far as the weird voting [results], I probably should be used to the surprises after all these seasons but I still find myself wondering how things go sometimes."
Fox
March 18, 2009: Alexis Grace Is Eliminated
"Judges made a BIG mistake ... this is the one time they should have exercised their save ... Alexis was a better singer then at least 3-5 other contestants and is cute to boot!"
-- Dsacco821
Fox
March 18, 2009: Alexis Grace Is Eliminated
"She should have sang that song as a soft ballad throughout the entire song, last night and tonight. She was trying to hard tonight to get that so-called 'dirty' sound. It wasn't suited for that song and she was too emotional to hit the notes tonight. A slow, soft version might have gotten her a reprieve."
-- Ferlin1890
Fox
March 18, 2009: Alexis Grace Is Eliminated
"Can anyone explain to me why Allison Iraheta was in the bottom 3 as I thought she was and still is one of the TOP 5 singers there? Are you telling me she got less votes than Megan, Lil, or even half the guys? I just can't believe that. What's going on here? It appears like another Michael Johns is brewing here."
-- CornStove7
Fox
March 18, 2009: Alexis Grace Is Eliminated
"I personally like Megan more than Alexis, but I like Alexis too. If one of the girls had to go I would have chosen Lil, but I think a guy should have gone (Scott, Michael, or Anoop). Top 10 consists of 7 guys and 3 girls now."
-- PineTreeHugs
Fox
March 11, 2009: Jorge Nunez Is Eliminated
"I was disappointed too that Jorge got the ax on the first show. Boooo. There were at least 4 others that could have gone first."
-- NiNi C 47
Fox
March 11, 2009: Anoop Desai Moves On
"I actually don't think [Jorge or Anoop] are good enough vocally to be the next American Idol but if I had to choose one to stay for me it would be Anoop over Jorge. In my opinion Anoop had more of the entertainment factor about him that made him more entertaining to watch and listen to."
Fox
Reader Comments (Page 4 of 16)
Adam is talented but I really don't like him. He definitely does not have that likability factor. I like Danny. He is talented and "normal". Megan should have gone first before anyone. Go figure!
Megan is horrible. I don't get why they keep saying she is unique. She reminds me of Alana Morisette who sings crappy too. Michael deserved to leave but not before Megan. Get her off. I can't stand to watch her week after week.
Megan is such a joke....she cannot sing..I agree with sending Michael home but Megan should have at least been in the bottom 3..the girl can't carry a tune in a bucket..I like Scott--although didn't agree with his song choice...Allison rocks!!!
I missed it last night...Who were the bottom 3?
I don't think that they made the right choice, I mean he isn't the best, but that girl should have went this week..... :)
For sure Megan should have gone home by now. But you know Simon is saving that big save for her.
megan should have been out but i agree michael should have been in the bottom two,i hope megan is out next week.
All u Megan haters have no taste in different music. All you people care about is the stuff that is out there right now. Megan has a unique voice that is suitable for jazzy blues songs. And Michael was the right choice going home.
My opinion, Adam will win. Scott and Megan should have gone weeks ago. They are up to the quality singers the rest are.
My opinion, Adam will win. Scott and Megan should have gone weeks ago. They are up to the quality singers the rest are.