American Idol' Season 8 Results
March 26, 2009: Michael Sarver Is Eliminated
"I knew he wouldn't win, but he was always a Southern gentleman with great manners. Kudos to him!"
-- WeezSqueez2
Fox
March 26, 2009: Michael Sarver Is Eliminated
"DANG it ... I am really bummed. NO WAY did he sing worse than Megan last night. She was a train wreck!"
-- taosunset200
Fox
March 26, 2009: Matt Giraud Lands in the Bottom 3
"Can someone tell me why Matt Giraud is in the bottom 3 when Simon complimented him for progressing to become one of the better singers in the competition and most people had him in the TOP 5? ... All the women thought he was sexy good! Something's wrong here ..."
-- CornStove7
Fox
March 26, 2009: Michael Sarver Is Eliminated
"Michael seemed like a very classy guy, glad ... he left with his head up. I wish him luck. As far as the weird voting [results], I probably should be used to the surprises after all these seasons but I still find myself wondering how things go sometimes."
Fox
March 18, 2009: Alexis Grace Is Eliminated
"Judges made a BIG mistake ... this is the one time they should have exercised their save ... Alexis was a better singer then at least 3-5 other contestants and is cute to boot!"
-- Dsacco821
Fox
March 18, 2009: Alexis Grace Is Eliminated
"She should have sang that song as a soft ballad throughout the entire song, last night and tonight. She was trying to hard tonight to get that so-called 'dirty' sound. It wasn't suited for that song and she was too emotional to hit the notes tonight. A slow, soft version might have gotten her a reprieve."
-- Ferlin1890
Fox
March 18, 2009: Alexis Grace Is Eliminated
"Can anyone explain to me why Allison Iraheta was in the bottom 3 as I thought she was and still is one of the TOP 5 singers there? Are you telling me she got less votes than Megan, Lil, or even half the guys? I just can't believe that. What's going on here? It appears like another Michael Johns is brewing here."
-- CornStove7
Fox
March 18, 2009: Alexis Grace Is Eliminated
"I personally like Megan more than Alexis, but I like Alexis too. If one of the girls had to go I would have chosen Lil, but I think a guy should have gone (Scott, Michael, or Anoop). Top 10 consists of 7 guys and 3 girls now."
-- PineTreeHugs
Fox
March 11, 2009: Jorge Nunez Is Eliminated
"I was disappointed too that Jorge got the ax on the first show. Boooo. There were at least 4 others that could have gone first."
-- NiNi C 47
Fox
March 11, 2009: Anoop Desai Moves On
"I actually don't think [Jorge or Anoop] are good enough vocally to be the next American Idol but if I had to choose one to stay for me it would be Anoop over Jorge. In my opinion Anoop had more of the entertainment factor about him that made him more entertaining to watch and listen to."
Fox
Reader Comments (Page 2 of 16)
The right person went home for sure, but it scared me when the judges were "undecided" about saving him. The only person worth saving is Adam. Adam is by far the best that has ever been on Idol. Lil should have been in the bottom 3 instead of Matt. Megan was my second favorite, but after Motown night, wow, that was bad. The bottome 3 next week should be Lil, Scott and Megan.
u cant say who should be on the bottom with out hearing them sing first.... and lil isnt bad. shes got a great voice. we all know dany gokey is gonna win anyway. IF they dont hae it rigged for a girl to win. since a guy won last year. and i hate megan. shes only there cuz of her looks. when she performs its like watching a train wreck. whats with that stupid wiggle thing she does everytime she sings?
i disagree, lil is excellent and should not be in the bottom three next week. she will be one of the top 5
I think being undecisive was an act. We all know that Simon has not cared for Michaels style from the beginning. But I did get nervous too. I think it will come down to only three people they will use the save on.
Megan is a HORRIBLE singer and should have been the one getting booted this week. pretty does not equal talented (though sometimes I think Simon wishes it did...). Michael was not idol material, so they did get that right.
Michael needed to go, but not before Megan! She has no rythem and just cannot sing. This reminds me of when Sanjaya was on the show. My husband had just got home from work when Megan was performing and said she is gone. I agreed. However Michael had to go also. But she wasn't even in the bottom 3. And what was up with Matt being in the bottom 3. I thought I would cry. I know he is not going to be our Idol, but he doesn't need to go before Megan. The girl doesn't even have any rythem to go with her singing, and we all know she can't sing. I think our top 3 will be LiL Rounds, Danny and Adam. I guess at this point though, they all get to tour. But Megan needs to go. Cute doesn't sell music!
I agree with your comments but learn to spell rhythm!
Meagan is a non-singer and hopefully she will be gone next week. The judges kept calling her relevant in the early weeks. What were they drinking? As a model, maybe! As far as I'm concerned, the top performers are Adam, Alyssa, Danny and Matt and any one of them deserve to be saved because any one of them could win the competition.
I wholeheartedly agree that Lil, Danny, and Adam should be in the top 3.
I agree with your top three(IilRounds, Adam, and Danny). I like megans voice. It is vey different but her dancing is terrible. I was surprised to see Alexis Grace leave before Michael. I really didn't think he was good from the start. I agree with someone else's comment that he would make a good country singer. Was displeased with his country week performance.