Feb. 20 (Top 12 Girls - '60s Night)
| Contestant | Song |
|---|---|
| Kristy Lee Cook | 'Rescue Me' (Fontella Bass) |
| Joanne Borgella | 'I Say a Little Prayer (Dionne Warwick) |
| Alaina Whitaker | 'More Today Than Yesterday' (Spiral Staircase) |
| Amanda Overmyer | 'Baby, Please Don't Go' (Van Morrison and Them) |
| Amy Davis | 'Where the Boys Are' (Connie Francis) |
| Brooke White | 'Happy Together' (The Turtles) |
| Alex Lushington | 'Spinning Wheel' (Blood, Sweat and Tears) |
| Kady Malloy | 'Groovy Kind of Love' (The Mindbenders) |
| Asia'H Epperson | 'Piece of My Heart' (Janis Joplin) |
| Ramiele Malubay | 'You Don't Have to Say You Love Me' (Dusty Springfield) |
| Syesha Mercado | 'Tobacco Road' (The Nashville Teens) |
| Carly Smithson | 'The Shadow of Your Smile' (Tony Bennett) |
Feb. 19 (Top 12 Boys - '60s Night)
| Contestant | Song |
|---|---|
| David Hernandez | 'In the Midnight Hour' (Wilson Pickett) |
| Chikezie Eze | 'More Today Than Yesterday' (Spiral Staircase) |
| David Cook | 'Happy Together' (The Turtles) |
| Jason Yeager | 'Moon River' (Audrey Hepburn) |
| Robbie Carrico | 'One' (Three Dog Night) |
| David Archuleta | 'Shop Around' (Smokey Robinson & the Miracles) |
| Danny Noriega | 'Jailhouse Rock' (Elvis Presley) |
| Luke Menard | 'Everybody's Talkin'' (Harry Nilsson) |
| Colton Berry | 'Suspicious Minds' (Elvis Presley) |
| Garrett Haley | 'Breaking Up Is Hard to Do' (Neil Sedaka) |
| Jason Castro | 'Daydream' (Lovin' Spoonful) |
| Michael Johns | 'Light My Fire' (The Doors) |